JV Stalin – Biographies, Reminiscences and Appraisals

Generalissimo Stalin

Generalissimo Stalin

More on the USSR

The Great ‘Marxist-Leninist’ Theoreticians

JV Stalin – Biographies, Reminiscences and Appraisals

Joseph Vissirionovich Stalin (Djugashvili – his family name) is a controversial figure to say the least. From the time he became the leader of both the Russian Communist Party (Bolshevik) in 1924, after the untimely death of the great Vladimir Ilyich Lenin (prematurely as a consequence of an assassination attempt in 1918) he has been vilified and denigrated by all those who seek to maintain the status quo of exploitation and oppression and the control of everything by a small minority.

In 1939 Chairman Mao wrote a short pamphlet entitled To be attacked by the enemy is not a bad thing but a good thing. The Chairman has also been subject to vicious slanders and calumnies, in the same way as ‘Uncle Joe’ before him. But we have only to look at those throwing the insults to consider that we should take a step back and not just follow the mindless herd.   

(For information about Stalin’s life, especially as it was represented in the art created in the Soviet Union before the Revisionists and reactionaries were able to gain control of the country, can be seen in the Stalin Museum in Gori.)

What follows is a selection of biographies (mostly) from a ‘pro-Stalin’ stance. I make no excuse about only including those which stress the positive aspects of Comrade Stalin’s time as not only leader of the Soviet Union (and its Communist Party) but also – until the end of World War II and the success of the Marxist-Leninist led Liberation movements in Albania and China – the leader of the International Communist Movement. 

If you want ‘the opposing view’ just open a newspaper (analogue or digital); turn on a radio or TV; open a book by the sycophantic and toadying authors whose mission is to create confusion and discord based upon shallow and doubtful ‘scholarship’; or (perhaps frighteningly so) listen to any of the politicians in what used to be socialist countries as they push anyone else away as they seek to get as deep as possible up the fundament of capitalism.

As such opposition to Stalin is so ubiquitous – and as (in the capitalist west, especially the UK with its lauded BBC with its remarkably prejudiced ‘impartiality’) you are supposed to look at both sides of the argument you will better spend your time downloading and reading some of the biographies made available here.

Biographies, Reminiscences and Appraisals

Stalin – a new world seen through one man, Henri Barbusse, Macmillan, New York, 1935, 315 pages.

Stalin, sixty years, M Kalinin, FLPH, Moscow, 1939, 98 pages. Published to celebrate Stalin’s sixtieth birthday.

Joseph Stalin – a short biography, Lawrence and Wishart, London, 1940, 96 pages. The first ‘official’ (so far as I’ve encountered – at least in English) biography of Stalin, produced by the Marx-Engels-Lenin Institute in Moscow and published in translation in London in 1940 – before the Soviet union was considered an ally of the UK in the war against Hitlerite Fascism.

Joseph Stalin, a short biography, compiled by G.F. Alexandrov, M.R. Galaktionov, V.S. Kruzhkov, M.B. Mitin, V.D. Mochalov, P.N. Pospelov, November 8th Publishing House, Ottawa, 2022, 176 pages.

Shaw on Stalin, Russia Today Society, London, June 1941, 11 pages. Correspondence between the Irish writer George Bernard Shaw and the Social-democratic magazine The New Statesman where there was a disagreement of the position that Stalin would take in the war against Hitlerite Fascism. Published by The Russia Today Society in June 1941, just a matter of days before the Hitlerite invasion of the Soviet Union

Stalin and the Red Army, KE Voroshilov, Foreign Languages Publishing House, Moscow, 1941, 62 pages. Reminiscences of the role that JV Stalin played in the Russian Civil War (and the War in Intervention by the capitalist powers) between 1918-1922. Written by one of those who fought at his side. Again published just before the invasion of the Soviet Union by the Hitlerite forces of Fascism.

Joseph Stalin – a short biography, Foreign Languages Publishing House, Moscow, 1942, 77 pages. A revised version of the 1941 biography published by the Marx-Engels-Lenin Institute and printed in London. This time a version printed in Moscow in 1942 – after the invasion by the Hitlerite Fascists.

Joseph Stalin – man of steel, DM Cole, Rich and Gowan, London, 1942, 136 pages, A biography written after the Hitlerite Fascist invasion of the Soviet Union just after the tide was beginning to turn against the invaders. A general look at the life of the Soviet leader. I can find no information about the author.

Landmarks in the life of Stalin, E Yaraslavsky, Lawrence and Wishart, London, 1942, 191 pages. A biography first published by the Foreign Languages Publishing House in Moscow in 1940 but which was reprinted in London as the interest in the background of the principle ally in the fight against Hitlerite Fascism grew after the invasion of the Soviet Union by the Nazi forces in June 1941. Yemelyan Yaroslavsky was a historian as well as a member of the Central Committee of the RCP from 1919. He was involved in the publication of a number of historical works of the Soviet Union – including the Civil War.

Stalin – 1879-1944, JT Murphy, John lane The Bodley Head, London, 1945, 251 pages. A biography written by a member of the Communist Party of Great (sic) Britain in 1945  after the Liberation of the country from Nazi Fascism in the Great Patriotic War. Murphy seemed to have quite personal access to Stalin at the time of his visits to the Soviet Union.

Joseph Stalin – a short biography, Foreign Languages Publishing House, Moscow, 1949, 207 pages. THE official biography of Stalin. Published in 1949, well after the defeat of Fascism, it was the last biography to be produced before the revisionist denunciation of Stalin (and consequently Lenin and all that the Revolution of 1917 meant for the workers and peasants of the world).

Stalin and the Armed Forces of the USSR, KE Voroshilov, Foreign Languages Publishing House, Moscow, 1951, 152 pages. A series of three articles written by Kliment Voroshilov on the 59th, 60th and 70th anniversary of the birth of Comrade Joseph Stalin.

My Uncle Joseph Stalin, Bude Svanidze, GP Putnam’s Sons, New York, 1953, 235 pages. Different from the other biographies that concentrate on the political situation in which Stalin lived. This is the reminiscences of a nephew who talks about Stalin and his relationships with his family – including Stalin’s three wives. (There’s an element of controversy about the provenance of this work. See the comments section on this blog.)

The Stalin Era, Anna Louise Strong, Mainstream Publishers, New York, 1956, 128 pages. ‘I think that, looking back, men will call it ‘the Stalin Era’. Tens of millions of people built the world’s first socialist state, but he was the engineer. he first gave voice to the thought that the peasant land of Russia could do it. from that time on, his mark was on all of it, on all the gains and all the evils.’ (From the Author’s Foreword)

Conversations with Stalin, Milovan Djilas, Penguin, London, 1967, 173 pages. Originally written in 1961, and giving Djilas’s reports of conversations in 1944, 1945 and 1948. Djilas was a long-time leader of the Communist Party of Yugoslavia, who developed into an open revisionist in his later years (even to the right of Tito!).

Centenary of the birth of JV Stalin, 8 Nentori Publishing House, Tirana, 1979, 119 pages. A photographic history of JV Stalin, including some rarely seen photos. Published in Tirana, Albania and with an emphasis on the importance Stalin played in the Liberation of the country and in the building of Socialism.

The Stalin Question, (Calcutta, Kathashilpa, 1979), 400 pages. An Anthology on the question of Stalin. Edited by Banbehari Chakrabarty. ‘Brings together most of the relevant materials – adequately prefaced and annotated – highlighting the basic aspects of the question as reflected in the writings of Lenin, Mao, Khrushchev, Voroshilov, Zhukov, Togliatti, Tito, Garaudy, Hoxha, Trotsky and Stalin.’

Stalin – man and ruler, Robert H McNeal, Macmillan, London, 1988, 389 pages.

Next to Stalin – notes of a bodyguard, AT Rybin, North Star Compass Journal, Toronto, 1996, 111 pages. Memoirs of a soldier who became one of Stalin’s bodyguards in 1931 until his death in 1953.

Another view of Stalin, Ludo Martens, EPO, Belgium, 1996, 179 pages. An analysis, and refutation, of the lies that have been perpetuated over the decades to vilify JV Stalin, not only to demonise the man himself but to place doubts in the minds of workers and peasants throughout the world that the solution to their problems is the building of Communism through the means of a revolutionary change of society. (An OCR scan from the original.)

A pictorial history of Joseph Stalin, Nigel Blundell, Sunburst Books, London, 1996, 96 pages. [The text and captions are banal but the pictures are good.]

Stalin – man of contradiction, Kenneth Neil Cameron, The Strong Oak Press, Stevenage, 1989, 203 pages. An evaluation of the life of JV Stalin which seeks to counter the simplistic, anti-Communist approach of many in the capitalist countries and, although not without faults, stresses the successes the Soviet Union achieved under his leadership.

With Stalin – memoirs, Enver Hoxha, 8 Nentori Publishing House, Tirana, 1979, 224 pages. Enver Hoxha’s reflections on his meetings with Comrade Stalin, published on the occasion of the Centenary of the Birth of the Great Marxist-Leninist Joseph Stalin.

The death of Stalin, Allan Wingate, London, 1958, 144 pages. An investigation by the ‘Monitor’ which comes to the conclusion that Stalin was murdered.

On overcoming the cult of the individual and its consequences, a Resolution of the Central Committee of the CPSU, June 30, 1956, Press Office of the USSR Embassy, Ottawa, 24 pages. This is part of the anti-Stalin campaign by Khrushchev and the CPSU after Stalin’s death.

Under the Banner of Stalin, writings by CPI General Secretary Ajoy Ghosh from 1952 to 1956, Ajoy Ghosh and the Communist Party of India’s response to the CPSU’s Resolution on Stalin’s Cult of Personality, Magpie Publishing, Kolkata, May 2022, 148 pages.

Lenin and Stalin on the development of the National Question, M.D. Kammari, November 8th Publishing House, Ottawa, 2023, 153 pages.

The Great Stalin is immortal, speeches and reports from the commemorative meeting and scientific session on the occasion of the centenary of the birth of JV Stalin, The November 8th Publishing Houses, Toronto, 2025, 156 pages. (The materials published in this book are epublished from the magazine Albania Today, 1 (50), 1980.)

The Stalin Society (UK) – publications.

More on the USSR

The Great ‘Marxist-Leninist’ Theoreticians

Peking Review – 1958

The young soldier helps to carry water

The young soldier helps to carry water

More on China …..

Peking Review – 1958

The first edition of Peking Review appeared on 4th March 1958. 

1958 was the year of the start of the ‘Great leap Forward’ – a revolutionary attempt to move China, which had been kept in a near feudalistic stage by foreign capital from the middle of the 19th century until Liberation in 1949, into the modern, industrial age.

If truth is the first victim of war it’s the last thing to appear when criticism is made of countries which attempt to build a new society which is not based upon exploitation and oppression of a minority over a majority. For that reason condemnations and criticisms made by capitalism and its cronies always have to be taken with a large pinch of salt. If all that happened after 1949 was such a disaster why is it now that capitalist (and increasingly imperialistic) China is able to threaten the capitalist countries that have been running the world for centuries?

The capitalist China of today is based on the wealth created by the struggles of the Chinese workers and peasants who, through their own efforts and (for most of the period of when Chairman Mao was at the helm of the country) having to face the hostility and isolation imposed upon it from the very beginning by the imperialists (mainly US imperialism) and later by the aggressive attitude of the erstwhile friend of workers struggles, the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics (USSR), when it started to follow the revisionist and capitalist road from the mid-1950s.

Even ‘statistics’ produced under the auspices of the powerful elite in charge of the Communist party of China in recent years have to be treated skeptically. Deng Xiaoping and his successors have even more to gain from denigrating the achievements before 1976 – otherwise their credibility comes to nought.

The articles published in the following issues of Peking Review will provide the reader with an opportunity to compare both sides of the argument. The reader will have to decide who to believe and consider context at the time as well as what they are being told today.

Topics and issues addressed in 1958:

  • China’s Economic Plan for 1958
  • ‘Two Chinas’ Hoax
  • great debate on the literary front
  • 12 year plan for agriculture
  • intellectuals go to the countryside
  • leaders must behave like ordinary workers
  • birthday greetings to Paul Robeson
  • workers and Trade Unions in China
  • regional autonomy for national minorities
  • Modern Revisionism must be repudiated
  • US intervention in Indonesia
  • ‘let’s all learn a little philosophy’
  • China’s monetary system
  • 2nd Session of the 8th National Congress of the Communist Party of China
  • introducing a Co-operative
  • Yugoslav Revisionism – product of Imperialist Policy
  • Korea in perspective
  • Ministers with Pick and Shovel
  • First Chinese Atomic Reactor
  • Romanticism and Realism
  • Stop US-British aggression in the Middle East
  • ‘On the Long March with Chairman Mao’
  • Mao Tse-tung and NS Khrushchov meet
  • higher education in China
  • Premier Chou En-Lai‘s statement on the situation in the Taiwan Straights Area
  • China’s Foreign Trade in 1958
  • water conservancy
  • Mao Tse-tung on ‘Imperialism and All Reactionaries are Paper Tigers’
  • Raise the Red Banner of the October Revolution still higher
  • Communist working spirit
  • family life – the new way
  • Anniversary of the Moscow Meetings of Communist and Workers’ parties
  • women builders of Socialism
  • expanding China’s railway network
  • Communique and Resolution of the 6th Plenary Session of the Central Committee of the Communist Party of China
  • Great Soviet Plan to Build Communism

Available issues of Peking Review:

1958, 1959, 1960, 1961, 1962, 1963, 1964, 1965, 1966, 1967, 1968, 1969, 1970, 1971, 1972, 1973, 1974, 1975, 1976, 1977, 1978

(There’s a Subject Index – for the whole year – at the end of Issue No. 44.)

Peking Review 1958 - 01

1958 – 01

Peking Review 1958 - 02

1958 – 02

Peking Review 1958 - 03

1958 – 03

Peking Review 1958 - 04

1958 – 04

 

 

 

 

 

Peking Review 1958 - 05

1958 – 05

Peking Review 1958 - 06

1958 – 06

Peking Review 1958 - 07

1958 – 07

Peking Review 1958 - 08

1958 – 08

 

 

 

 

 

Peking Review 1958 - 09

1958 – 09

Peking Review 1958 - 10

1958 – 10

Peking Review 1958 - 11

1958 – 11

Peking Review 1958 - 12

1958 – 12

 

 

 

 

 

Peking Review 1958 - 13

1958 – 13

Peking Review 1958 - 14

1958 – 14

Peking Review 1958 - 15

1958 – 15

Peking Review 1958 - 16

1958 – 16

 

 

 

 

 

Peking Review 1958 - 17

1958 – 17

Peking Review 1958 - 18

1958 – 18

Peking Review 1958 - 19

1958 – 19

Peking Review 1958 - 20

1958 – 20

 

 

 

 

 

Peking Review 1958 - 21

1958 – 21

Peking Review 1958 - 22

1958 – 22

Peking Review 1958 - 23

1958 – 23

Peking Review 1958 - 24

1958 – 24

 

 

 

 

 

Peking Review 1958 - 25

1958 – 25

Peking Review 1958 - 26

1958 – 26

Peking Review 1958 - 27

1958 – 27

Peking Review 1958 - 28

1958 – 28

 

 

 

 

 

Peking Review 1958 - 29

1958 – 29

Peking Review 1958 - 30

1958 – 30

Peking Review 1958 - 31

1958 – 31

Peking Review 1958 - 32

1958 – 32

 

 

 

 

 

Peking Review 1958 - 33

1958 – 33

Peking Review 1958 - 34

1958 – 34

Peking Review 1958 - 35

1958 – 35

Peking Review 1958 - 36

1958 – 36

 

 

 

 

 

Peking Review 1958 - 37

1958 – 37

Peking Review 1958 - 38

1958 – 38

Peking Review 1958 - 39

1958 – 39

Peking Review 1958 - 40

1958 – 40

 

 

 

 

 

Peking Review 1958 - 41

1958 – 41

Peking Review 1958 - 42

1958 – 42

Peking Review 1958 - 43

1958 – 43

Peking Review 1958 - 44

1958 – 44

 

 

 

 

 

Beijing Review

From issue No. 1 of 1979 the weekly political and informative magazine Peking Review changed its name to Beijing Review. On page 3 of that number the editors made the open declaration of the change in the direction of the erstwhile ‘People’s Republic of China’.

By stating that the Communist Party of China (under the control then of Teng Hsiao-Ping/Deng Xiaoping ) sought

‘to accomplish socialist modernisation by the end of the century and turn China …. into an economically developed and fully democratic socialist country’

the CPC was openly declaring the rejection of the revolutionary path, which the country had been following since 1949, and the adoption of the road that would inevitably lead to the full scale establishment of capitalism.

For those who would like to follow this downward spiral into the murky depths of capitalism and imperialism in the issues of Beijing Review (complete for the years 1979-1990 – intermittently thereafter) you can do so by going to bannedthought – which also serves as an invaluable resource for more material about China during its revolutionary phase.

More on China …..

Peking Review 1958-1978

Always keep a firm grip on the rifle

Always keep a firm grip on the rifle

More on China …..

Peking Review

Soon after Chairman Mao made the Declaration of the of the People’s Republic of China in Tienanmen Square on 1st October 1949 the Communist Party of China decided that the production of a regular magazine, which would tell the world what the Chinese were attempting to create in their country, was of paramount importance. From January 1950 a magazine called People’s China was produced fortnightly until the end of 1957. This was superseded by the weekly magazine Peking Review.

Peking Review (in English) was first published in March 1958 and then continued, on a weekly basis, until the first issue of 1979 (January 5th) when it was re-branded as Beijing Review.

Unfortunately the new name also presaged a new direction. From being a revolutionary magazine, presenting the ideas and aspirations of a young (and relatively weak) Socialist state struggling along the road to the construction of Communism it has now become the open statement of aims of an outright capitalist and imperialist state – with global ambitions.

As Mao famously wrote; ‘a revolution is not a dinner party’ (Report on an Investigation of the Peasant Movement in Hunan (March 1927), Selected Works, Vol. I, p. 28.) and this means that from the very beginning the new Socialist state had to face many obstacles. There is opposition from within and without the country, from within and without the Party. Those who might have played an important role in the past in the fight for liberation are not necessarily the ones who are needed to build a radically new society. All revolutionaries bring with them the baggage of the capitalist past – some find it more difficult than others to throw off that hindrance. 

A study of all revolutions shows this to be the case and, learning from the experience of the past, Chairman Mao promoted the Cultural Revolution (which started in 1966) to expose such elements within the Party and Government structure – at all levels. This means that in the early editions of Peking Review articles written by, or about, certain individuals who were later denounced and condemned appear. Not all of what they said at that time might have been incorrect but as the struggle to build Socialism intensifies the contradictions between them and the revolutionary wing of the Party and people will inevitably come into conflict. And all conflict must have a resolution.  

All the issues that covered the revolutionary period, which included important developments such as ‘The Great Leap Forward’; the collectivisation of the countryside; the industrialisation of a previously backward, feudal society; developments in education, social welfare, health and culture; and, especially, ‘The Great Socialist Cultural Revolution’ are all documented in the pages of Peking Review from 1958-1976.

Very soon after the death of Chairman Mao Tse-tung (Mao Zedong), on 9th September 1976, those achievements came under attack by the ‘capitalist roaders’ (represented by the arch-traitor to the Chinese workers and peasants, Teng Hsiao-ping (Deng Xiaoping) and not so gradually those achievements were turned into the ‘primitive accumulation’ of the present day Chinese billionaires.

For a look at the development of literature, art and culture during the Socialist period of China’s past you can do worse than have a look at the issues of Chinese Literature.

Available issues of Peking Review:

1958, 1959, 1960, 1961, 1962, 1963, 1964, 1965, 1966, 1967, 1968, 1969, 1970, 1971, 1972, 1973, 1974, 1975, 1976, 1977, 1978

Beijing Review

From issue No. 1 of 1979 the weekly political and informative magazine Peking Review changed its name to Beijing Review. On page 3 of that number the editors made the open declaration of the change in the direction of the erstwhile ‘People’s Republic of China’.

By stating that the Communist Party of China (under the control then of Teng Hsiao-Ping/Deng Xiaoping ) sought ‘to accomplish socialist modernisation by the end of the century and turn China …. into an economically developed and fully democratic socialist country’ the CPC was openly declaring the rejection of the revolutionary path, which the country had been following since 1949, and the adoption of the road that would inevitably lead to the full scale establishment of capitalism.

More on China …..